Tuesday, June 23, 2009

The Brief Wonderous Life Of Oscar Wao

I was pretty excited to read this book. It was recommended by a friend. I typically do not read award winning books without hearing about them from friends. Just cause it won awards doesn't mean I'll like it.
I was enthralled by the first chapter. I knew people like Oscar. Occasionally I felt like Oscar. But then we switched to his sister, then his mother, then his grandfather, then his friend, Yunior. I liked hearing Oscar's story more or less from his own mouth.
I struggled with the paragraph sized footnotes towards the beginning of the book. I felt like I was reading a text book. I felt like I needed a Spanish dictionary to understand some of the converstations. Toward the middle of the book, I was just reading to finish it.
The writing is beautiful and you feel like you are in a different place. Diaz paints a stunningly real picture of these people's lives. I went into the book wanting to hear about Oscar and heard more about his family than I wanted. I know sometimes hearing the past can help you understand the future or the present but I felt like there were a couple of different books rivaling each other. It felt like too much and Oscar's story was lost along the way.
I'm sad that I did not enjoy this book more.

4 comments:

Rachel said...

I felt exactly the same way when I read it! I had many moments when I identified with Oscar's outsider/marginal status, especially at the start -- but the story derailed, and then it just petered out at the end (events notwithstanding).

I was sorry to feel that way when I was done, especially since I had been so excited to finally get my hands on a copy, but that's honestly how I felt. Ultimately I think this particular book was overrated and overhyped, and it was disappointing to me.

moonrat said...

I quite enjoyed this novel, but to be honest I, too, was pretty disappointed about the composition, especially the several uneven intents in the narrative and the bouncing voice.

Mel u said...

Diaz's collection of short stories "Drown" is at least as good as Oscar Wao maybe better, to me it felt more real.

Staci said...

Sounds like there is too much of a good thing and like you noted too many stories going on all at the same time. I may try this book but I'm not going to run out to grab it that's for sure!! Great review Linda!!